Present Estates Pt 2 – Defeasible Fees

Assessment Questions

Question 1

Which of the following statements about defeasible fees is not true?
a
Defeasible fees are devisable and descendible.
b
Defeasible fees require a duration.
c
If a defeasible fee creates a future interest in a third party, it’s a fee simple subject to an executory interest.
d
Defeasible fees can place absolute restraints on either the use of land or the sale of land.
Explanation
Defeasible fees allow a grantor to control the grantee’s use of the property by placing some condition on the grantee’s possession. While restraints on use are valid, absolute restraints on the grantee’s ability to sell the land are void because the law favors alienability. Defeasible fees can be passed on by will or intestacy (i.e., they are devisable and descendible), and they do require magic words signifying some duration, like “so long as,” “while,” “until,” or “but if.” Two kinds of defeasible fees—fee simple determinable and fee simple subject to condition subsequent—create future interests in the grantor. The third kind—fee simple subject to an executory interest—creates a future interest in a third party.

Question 2

Owen is a cat person. He wants his daughter, Alice, to live on the family farm, but only if she promises to keep the place cat-friendly. He makes the following grant: from Owen to Alice, but if Alice adopts a dog, Owen has the power of termination. Which of these statements about the grant is not true?
a
It conveys to Alice a fee simple subject to condition subsequent.
b
Even if Alice adopts a dog, she may not lose her possessory interest.
c
It conveys to Alice a fee simple subject to executory limitation.
d
The rule against perpetuities does not apply to this grant.
Explanation
This grant contains the magic words that signal it is a fee simple subject to condition subsequent: “but if.” In this type of present estate, the grantor retains the right to reenter—also called the power of termination—if the grantee violates the condition. But the right to reenter is merely an option. Alice doesn’t lose her interest automatically; Owen could either exercise his option or choose to overlook Alice’s violation. The rule against perpetuities does not apply to fees simple subject to condition subsequent because they create a future interest in the grantor.

Lesson Note

No note. Click here to write note.

Click here to reset

Leave a Reply